Circulus in Probando

Circular Reasoning

Closely related to Begging the Question is Circulus in Probondo (circular reasoning). This faulty logic occurs when the premise of an argument is recycled or re-worded in the argument's conclusion.

Basically, the point in contention is used to "prove" itself. Note these interesting examples below.

Example:

Students want to learn at QSI Haiphong because QSI Haiphong is where students want to learn! #GoStallions

Example:

Everyone loves Rebecca because she is so popular!

Example:

You must obey the law because it is illegal to break the law!

Idiocracy (2006)

Attorney General: Brawndo's got what plants crave.

Secretary of Energy: Yeah, it's got electrolytes.

Joe: What are electrolytes? Do you even know?

Secretary of State: It's what they use to make Brawndo.

Joe: Yeah, but why do they use them to make Brawndo?

Secretary of Defense: 'Cause Brawndo's got electrolytes.

Example:

Employer: Wow, your résumé looks great! I do need another reference, though.

Applicant: My friend Hector will have good things to say about me, so I'll call him. He'll tell you.

Applicant: How do I know that Hector is trustworthy?

Applicant: Oh, I can vouch for him.

More examples:

I’m always right because I’ve never been wrong.
The cake is delicious because it tastes good.
Dogs are better than cats because cats aren’t as good as dogs.
I know he’s trustworthy because he told me he is.
This chair is comfortable because sitting in it feels comfy.
Coffee wakes me up because I don’t feel awake without coffee.
Pineapple belongs on pizza because pizza can have pineapple.
Unicorns exist because I believe in unicorns.
Mondays are terrible because they’re the worst day of the week.
This is the best movie because no other movie is as good.
I’m late because I didn’t get here on time.
This restaurant is popular because lots of people eat here.
He’s cool because everyone thinks he’s cool.
This rule is important because it must be followed.
I’m smart because I always say smart things.
This is true because it’s not false.
I’m not lying because I’m telling the truth.
That’s a fact because it’s factual.
I win arguments because I never lose.
It’s obvious because it’s clear.
Homework is important because it must be done.
It’s raining because water is falling from the sky.
I’m hungry because I need food.
This hat looks good because it fits my head.
Ice cream is the best dessert because no dessert is better than ice cream.
Dogs bark because they are dogs.
That’s the answer because it’s correct.
It’s illegal because the law says so.
I’m tired because I need sleep.
Pizza is food because we eat it.
This is funny because I laughed.
It’s scary because it’s frightening.
I believe it because it’s believable.
He’s the leader because he’s in charge.
I’m cold because I don’t feel warm.
It’s wrong because it isn’t right.
This is art because it was made by an artist.
I’m the boss because I’m in charge.
It’s correct because it’s not incorrect.
I’m special because I’m unique.
This is a good idea because it’s not a bad idea.
It’s obvious because you should see it.
It’s mine because I own it.
This is the answer because I said so.
He’s fast because he runs quickly.
It’s fun because I enjoy it.
That’s the rule because that’s the rule.
She’s nice because she’s kind.
I’m right because you’re wrong.
This is fair because it’s not unfair.
I’m cool because I’m awesome.
That’s hot because it’s not cold.
I’m the winner because I didn’t lose.
It’s love because it feels like love.
It’s safe because it isn’t dangerous.
I’m funny because people laugh at my jokes.
This is music because it makes sound.
I’m tall because I’m not short.
This is necessary because you can’t go without it.
It’s true because it’s not false.
I know this is correct because it isn’t wrong.
He’s famous because everyone knows him.
It’s hot outside because the weather is warm.
It’s broken because it doesn’t work.
I’m the best because no one is better.
It’s confusing because it doesn’t make sense.
That’s valuable because it’s worth a lot.
It’s a circle because it’s round.
This is amazing because it’s incredible.
I’m awake because I’m not asleep.
It’s easy because it’s simple.
He’s brave because he’s not scared.
This is proof because it proves my point.
She’s right because she’s not wrong.
That’s the law because it’s illegal.
It’s obvious because you should know it.
This is fair because everyone gets the same.
I’m strong because I can lift things.
It’s necessary because you need it.
It’s delicious because it tastes great.
I know it’s true because it can’t be false.
He’s honest because he doesn’t lie.
This is better because it’s superior.
It’s correct because the answer isn’t wrong.
This is real because it exists.
I’m awake because I opened my eyes.
It’s useful because you can use it.
That’s silly because it’s ridiculous.
It’s important because it matters.
This is normal because it’s not weird.
I’m hungry because I want food.
It’s night because it’s dark outside.
This is magic because it’s mysterious.
He’s tall because he’s not short.
That’s funny because it’s hilarious.
It’s wrong because it’s incorrect.
I’m busy because I have things to do.
It’s weird because it’s strange.
I’m bored because I don’t have fun.
It’s circular reasoning because it goes in circles.

Page updated

Google Sites

Report abuse